Tag: Sullivan Catskills

We haven’t been to Siena’s Pizzeria in Monticello in over 5 plus years. It was always a hit or miss with the pizza. Some days it was good and others not so good. That is the main story for most of the pizzerias around us. I’m trying to get videos and feedback on all the local pizzerias in my area. We decided to give Siena another try while my brother was visiting.

Siena’s Pizza Address: 321 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Siena’s Pizza Hours: 

Siena’s Pizza Phone: (845) 791-7662

We got one plain cheese pizza and it looked nice and crispy from the top but when you look at the undercarriage there was no crunch or char. The cheese and sauce tasted okay but I just wish the dough had more crunch to it. You can see in the video I shared on Youtube.

Would you try this pizza based on the picture? Comment below if you would try pizza from Siena’s in Monticello, NY.